Celebrate! You Made It Happen!

June 29, 2015      Roger Craver

Anyone with a heart and soul is celebrating Friday’s U.S. Supreme Court decision on marriage equality.

The fundraising blogs are alive with the celebratory news. Tom Ahern and his partner Simone Joyaux report their giving patterns will now change. Hopefully, and surely, the Human Rights Campaign will be wringing mega $$ from the jaws of victory.

I don’t want to let this glorious moment pass without recognizing those long ago folks who got this all started. Those who stuck their necks out 45 years ago taking action on what had to be done when GLBT surely wasn’t cool.

To the fundraisers of the 60s and 70s and 80s goes a lot of credit because they fueled that engine of change. It’s one thing to catch today’s stock photo of kissing marriage ceremonies on TV and quite another to recall the secret words, messages and techniques we had to use to get this all underway in a world where social opprobrium and possibly jail time were realities.

flagMy point though isn’t about nostalgia. It’s about recognizing how long and how hard the fight always is for significant change. A reminder to all fundraisers in this space — especially the young: You shouldn’t be in the social change fundraising business unless you’re mentally dressed in rugged trousers and boots and prepared for the long haul.

No sooner had the Stonewall riots in New York occurred in June of 1969 then Ira Glasser, then of the New York ACLU, announced that organization’s support for the right to gay marriage. Most folks thought he was bonkers. It seemed quixotic then, but here we are today. Now he’s a hero.

As Ira used to say in his debates with The National Review’s William F. Buckley: “The ACLU is rarely wrong, but is very often prematurely right.”

Change occurs very, very slowly. Ours is not a trade for the impatient.

If you’ve ever wondered whether your skills make a difference, let me tell you about my own experience with the gay underground in those days. Days when being ‘queer’ could cost you your job … your standing in the community … your very livelihood.

I was blessed to find a group of young, committed and fearless gay activists who wanted to fight the homophobic system and make political gains. They were both energetic and studious.

Sean Strub, in his remarkable book on the early history of gay activism in the late 20th Century, Body Counts, covers a lot of what went into that early movement toward gay equality. Whatever your orientation, you need to read Sean’s book to understand the pathos and suffering of that period, covering both the fight for rights and then the later battle against the blight and terror of AIDS.

Fundraisers were essential to the modern gay rights movement.

Money, as always, is the fuel that drives the engine of change.

I remember giving my gay friends and co-conspirators advice. Sean describes it this way in his book:

“Craver explained response rates, average gifts, how to calculate the cost per thousand and revenue per thousand, and what made a fund-raising letter work. He taught me the mechanics of database manipulation, response analysis, and innovative production techniques. He explained what type of celebrities worked best to sign fund-raising appeals; why some colors of paper and shapes, sizes, and types of envelopes pulled a better response than others; and why a stamp affixed to an envelope slightly crooked produced a better response than a straight one.”

Whatever I did, I’m sure glad I did it. And, I know how long it takes to make the world better, safer and more equal for all of us. This is why we do what we do.

Are you rejoicing or damning the Supreme Court’s decision on marriage equality? Why?

Roger

P.S. In almost every historic social policy change in the 20th and 21st centuries fundraisers figure prominently. Here’s a link to a little orientation lesson I used to give to those new folks joining the ranks of Craver, Mathews, Smith.

4 responses to “Celebrate! You Made It Happen!”

  1. That’s why we love being fundraisers — changing the world in historic ways is a damn good day job. Let’s tackle the NRA next and pass some sensible gun laws in our country.

  2. Gail Perry says:

    Thanks for reminding us, Roger, of our vitally important role.

    It’s so heartening to see all of our activist work finally, finally take hold. The nonprofit activists never stopped. They (we) all carried on and on and on.

    Yes! to Roger’s comment that it can take a long, long time. I remember the optimistic 70’s when we thought we could change the world. Kudos to all the people who have never ever stopped the fight.

    The only way we’ll ever change the world is to be rabble-rousers. And never, ever stopping.

    Take heart my colleagues. Every single thing we do matters. It’s not in vain. It forwards the conversation and moves the world. Hurray for you and hurray for all of us!

  3. As one of the many LGBT beneficiaries of the SCOTUS decision on marriage, I share your joy over the ruling Roger. I am also even more committed to fighting for all the rights and protections that LGBT people still lack. Being “queer” can still cost you your livelihood in 29 states where there is no protection against being fired for your sexual orientation. Your gender identify can get you fired in 32 states. So while we celebrate this historic achievement, let’s please view this as one more step forward in the long road to justice.

  4. Thank you, Roger, for this piece. And the comments from Tina and Gail. I often tell my story of giving to the LGBTQ fund at the Rhode Island Foundation. And when I tell the story (also included in KEEP YOUR DONORS), I tear up. The best solicitation I ever experienced, when the fund asked Tom and me for a gift. They knew us. They honored us. We were the first straight people they asked for a gift from. And that always makes me cry.

    SOCIAL JUSTICE. That’s what Tom and I care about so very very very deeply. I saw Daryl Upsall (your pal, Roger) in D.C. early in June. And he was telling me the story of working for Nelson Mandela. I admire you both so much.

    The fight isn’t over for equity. EQUITY is different than equality. Just because there is now marriage equality doesn’t mean that homophobia is gone. We all know darn well (I would have preferred to use the other word)… that racism, sexism, homophobia are alive and well in this country of ours.

    So Tom and I will continue those fights. My newest client is the Center for Constitutional Rights. Litigation around LGBT issues…government and national security, Guantanamo, international human rights, etc. etc. I just spent 3 days with them in NYC. I may be falling in love with them. So we can spread our social justice money in some new places.

    Donors fulfill their own aspirations by giving through organizations. I want equity. Many of us want equity. And donors – in partnership with fundraisers and organizations – can make change.

    Congratulations to all of us.