“Because It Works” Is Doing a Lot of Work
“Because it works” is an all-purpose permission slip for fake urgency, mystery matches, emails pretending you’ve been having a conversation with someone who couldn’t pick you out of a two-person lineup. Somewhere, a test is declared a winner and all is settled.
A Princeton-led study, published in 2023, analyzed more than 300,000 political emails during the 2020 election cycle. The median active sender used clickbait or deceptive inbox tactics in 42% of emails. And, in a rare bout of bipartisanship, both sides did it equally.
The tricks included fabricated conversation threads, “Re:” and “Fwd:” on messages that weren’t replies or forwards, and sender names that concealed who was contacting you.
Then there’s what happens after the open. As emails progressed, their sentences became less related to their subject lines. Near the end, a sentence was about as likely to match a random subject line from the same sender. The researchers call this “pivoting to fundraising.” That’s an awfully polite description of bait and switch.
The consequences extend beyond an irritated inbox with negative PR galore from media exposés with old people who were misled into giving away millions.
The matching multipliers haven’t calmed down either. A September 2026 House Majority PAC email promised a 900% match. Apparently ordinary multiplication is no longer polling well. Election deadlines create an obvious incentive to collect money now and worry about the relationship later. Charities borrowing these tactics still have a mission to fund after Giving Tuesday.
A tactic can raise more money today but that doesn’t establish what it does to donor understanding, trust or future giving. A test that measures this week’s revenue can’t answer questions it never bothered to ask. Refunds, regret and attrition don’t disappear because the dashboard lacks a column for them.
The behavioral ambition should be donors who understand their contribution, feel capable of making a difference and choose to stay involved. Confusing someone into giving tells us very little about any of that.
Make sure the “because it works” doesn’t mean you counted tomorrow’s dollars and then stopped counting and declared victory.
Kevin



