Hal Malchow’s Last Campaign

March 18, 2024      Roger Craver

No wonder my phone exploded yesterday.

This headline explains why:

“Hal Malchow Is Going to Die on Thursday.  He has One Last Message for Democrats.”

The subhead continued, “The pioneering Democratic consultant has been planning his death for decades.”

In his inimitable style of facts salted with grace, compassion and deep knowledge  of the American political consulting jungle Sasha Isssenberg  rocked us all with this  lede in his Saturday piece in Politico, “On Thursday, March 21, one of the Democratic party’s most accomplished campaign consultants will die.”

Sasha’s article continues…”In a sense, Hal Malchow has been planning for this day ever since 1987, when a genetic marker test revealed he was likely to develop Alzheimer’s. At the time, he was barely 35 years old, a hustling political operative who had recently come off managing Al Gore’s first Senate campaign while overcome with worry about his mother’s early descent into dementia. (Around her 50th birthday, she was discovered wandering lost in a parking lot in the Mississippi town where she had lived her whole life.) After his mother’s untimely death, in 1990, Malchow was intent on never letting himself endure the same thing. If he showed symptoms for Alzheimer’s, Malchow resolved at the time, he would take his life before he became too diminished — and became a burden to those around him.”

I urge you to read the entire piece.  In it you’ll find insight into and examples of the skill, persistence, and courage of one of the most remarkable colleagues in our trade. Just as importantly, you’ll gain fresh appreciation for the level of commitment, tenacity, and yes plain stubbornness, it takes to make change while swimming against the rip tide of conventional wisdom swirling in consulting’s  Sea of Sameness.

 Right after I reviewed Hal’s latest book Reinventing Political Advertising   [See Agitator’s Correcting a $16 Billion Mistake] I called to thank him for this important work.  He told me about his condition and his decision. My emotions range out and back from shock, and helplessness, to sadness and confusion, but mostly to admiration and respect.

So, Hal I’m not gonna wait ‘til you can’t read your own obit.

Here’s The Agitator’s shout out to you with all our love, respect, and admiration.

In the ever-changing landscape  of American political consulting and fundraising. (Currently a fever swamp filled with too much  greed, corruption, idolatry of convention and self-interest)  few professionals have redefined the battlegrounds on which campaigns are won and lost.

Hal Malchow stands among these pioneers, not just for the groundbreaking strides he’s made in political campaigning but for his bold and dignified final chapter.

As we celebrate Hal’s  remarkable professional and personal journey, we most honor his  power of choice, courage, and his indomitable spirit to challenge the status quo — in life, work, and all the moments that define us.

Innovator, Visionary, Trailblazer

For over three decades, Hal Malchow has pushed the boulder  of change uphill.  Perhaps a real-life  Sisyphus, but with a crucial difference: Hal moved political mountains—or at least has implanted sufficient intellectual and data-drive dynamite into the massive hump of conventional wisdom to eventually blast it apart.

By harnessing the untapped potential of direct mail and placing unwavering faith in data over tradition, he revolutionized how to reach voters and engage the electorate. His pioneering spirit didn’t stop at merely questioning the conventional and highly profitable wisdom of relying on expensive television spots; it will eventually dismantle it, proving through academic research and collaboration and proven practical application there are more effective, lower cost ways to communicate, mobilize and win.

No wonder that despite Hal’s induction into the Hall of Fame of the American Association of Political Consultants when his first revolutionary book– The New Political Targeting –shook up the political consulting world some members of that august body plotted on how to best suppress it.

Mentor to Change Missionaries

Hal’s influence extends far beyond his own achievements . One of his most lasting legacies lies in the young minds he’s inspired and trained — a veritable cadre of change missionaries when it comes to the practice of politics. Through his guidance, this next generation of strategists and campaigners are imbued with Hal’s questioning spirit, his reliance on data, and his courage to challenge the “same-old, same-old.” In short,  armed with Malchow’s teachings and ethos, they’re poised to dismantle outdated conventions, ensuring that our democracy is not only preserved but strengthened.

A Personal Journey of Determination

Hal’s professional tenacity is mirrored in his personal life. Faced with the harrowing genetic forecast of Alzheimer’s — a disease that deeply affected his family — he made a vow early on. He would not let the disease define his final chapters. This decision, rooted in the same courage and foresight that guided his career, have brought him, alongside his devoted wife and son, to Switzerland. There, in an act of profound autonomy, Hal will embrace a peaceful end on his own terms, surrounded by love and serenity — far from the screeching political arenas destined for reform.

The Legacy of a Pathfinder

Malchow’s legacy is not just in the campaigns he shaped or the victories he engineered. It lies in the fearless pursuit of innovation, the embrace of change, and the seeds of courage he planted in the next generation of political strategists. His work has left an indelible mark on political strategy, voter outreach, and the very fabric of democratic engagement. Yet, it’s his final act of self-determination that perhaps most vividly captures the essence of his pioneering spirit.

In this, what might be seen as his final campaign (although personally, I doubt it), Hal teaches us the ultimate lesson in autonomy and courage. His choice, made with clarity and love, underscores the profound respect for life’s journey and the dignity of deciding its course.

My Note to Hal:  Your pioneering spirit, your groundbreaking work, your courageous final act, and your indelible influence on tomorrow is an inspiration. You’ve not only changed the way campaigns are run but also shone a light on the path to facing life’s most challenging decisions with grace.

Thank you, Hal, for everything.

Roger

P.S.  For readers who want to fully understand and appreciate the enormity of Hal’s contribution in the context of today’s politics I recommend you read Sasha Issenberg’s The Victory Lab: The Secret Science of Winning CampaignsPolitico calls it the “Moneyball for politics.”

And if you’d like to get a flavor of Hal’s current thinking on  how to win campaign in 2024 check out the podcast he recently did with a former staffer Joe Fuld.

16 responses to “Hal Malchow’s Last Campaign”

  1. Barry Cox says:

    Tremendous tribute to a towering figure.

  2. Thank you Roger for this beautifully written tribute to Hal. You have introduced him to so many that didn’t get the chance to work with him and know his brilliance first hand. What a tremendous legacy Hal leaves us with.

  3. Jennie Thompson says:

    Beautiful tribute to a pioneer — even now he shows us how to think differently about assumptions we may have — as he has nudged us throughout his ground breaking career. Thank you, Hal.

  4. Frank OBrien says:

    Roger, what a wonderful tribute capturing the grace, determination and impact of Hal’s brilliant career and life. As always, you gave voice to what so many of us are feeling today.

  5. Chuck Pruitt says:

    I can think of no one who has meant more to our industry and our larger community than Hal Malchow. He pushed the boundaries and challenged assumptions in a way few have or ever will. A
    nd now, in this final chapter, he is reminding us all of the importance of having the ability and right to choose your own ending. Thank you, Hal, for all you have given all of us. Thank you, Roger, for a compelling and well-deserved tribute.

  6. Harvey McKinnon says:

    Thanks Roger, a wonderful tribute. Hal’s book arrived last week, and thank you for alerting me to this great resource. I look forward to his wisdom.

    And may I encourage all of us who have been inspired by Hals’ life and work to do everything we can to make sure that the extremist right is kept out of office -everywhere. Hal would like that, I think.

  7. Frank OBrien says:

    Roger, thanks for this wondeeful tribute to Hal’s brilliant career and life. As always, you’ve given voice to what so many of us are feeling.

  8. Helen P. Wellborn says:

    Dear Hal, I often think of the times we played hide and seek in your yard in Gulfport. Davey, Ricky, Ginger and Charles Wellborn and me. The sun was beating down on the humidity and the seashell drie way was crunching under our bare feet and oh the screaming and yelling full of wildness. I can still smell the salty air.

    HP Wellborn

  9. Jennifer Jones Ingram says:

    Thank you for such a moving tribute, Roger. I only got to work with Hal briefly in my career, but I know the tremendous impact he has had on so many of us in this industry. Hal, thank you for showing us the way on so many things. You will be greatly missed.

  10. Karin Kirchoff says:

    I had the privilege of working for Hal on the Gore presidential direct mail in the late 90s. What an icon. I learned so much. So much so that I’m bought his most recent book for a client who is running a long shot Senate campaign in a deep red state. Hal’s influence lives on. Appreciate your perspective Roger. Thank you.

  11. Lori O’Brien says:

    Roger, you found the words so many of us lack when describing Hal. In your words, I am one of his change missionaries who still uses his brilliant spreadsheets and counts his colleagues as my lifelong friends. Hal, you prove that humor and curiosity go a long way.

  12. Jody Shear Glaser says:

    Thank you for this tribute. Hal was my first boss right out of college and I will forever remember how much I admired him and how much he taught me. He will be truly missed but we will all remember how he affected our lives in such wonderful ways and also how he had such a great impact on all of the work he did.

  13. Cecilia Saad says:

    Thank you for this, Roger.

    Hal, landing at MA&H early in my career was a charmed turn of fate. Your gleeful willingness to hold up your own professional goofs as teaching moments for the rest was both profound and hilarious. One of my own goofs landed me on the wrong side of a Packers bet after which you sentenced me to wearing a styrofoam Cheesehead from 9-5. Losing has never tasted so sweet. We all lived to make you smile.

  14. Betsy Hubby Wood says:

    This is a lovely tribute to Hal, Roger. I started at Malchow & Company in that tiny office on Dupont Circle, and worked with him for most of the 90’s. I learned so much from him in those formative years, and I look back on that chapter in my life fondly. I will be forever grateful for the fine caliber of people with whom I had the good fortune to work and know. We worked hard and laughed a lot!

    Hal, thank you for always believing in me and pushing me to be the best version of myself.

  15. Jen Boland says:

    The news of Hal’s decision hit me hard. I got to know Hal because an investor in a startup I worked at. He was brilliant and I loved watching him push the envelope.

    My mom is currently dying of Alzheimer’s. It is a horrid disease and I respect Hal’s decision not to go through it, but even moreso not to put his family through it.

  16. Anne Marsh says:

    Roger,
    This is Hal’s wife, Anne Marsh. Thank you so much for this beautiful tribute. Hal realized that you had gotten a copy of the unedited book and had requested I send one of the new versions to you. I do not have your snail mail address to do this. How, of course, had a huge email list of everybody, but I’m not as good with lists as he was 🤣

    Please send your snail mail address and I will get the new copy to you ASAP.