We Interrupt This Mission to Bring You a Tumbler
In Japan, taxpayers can take welding lessons near Mt. Fuji, test drive a Porsche or serve as mayor for a day. All they have to do is send those towns some of their tax dollars.
Japan’s “hometown tax” system lets taxpayers donate to towns or cities where they don’t live, receive tax relief and collect a gift in return. What began as a way to help rural places losing population has become a gifting arms race.
Former Prime Minister Yoshihide Suga helped create the program and said he donates to the town where he grew up in a family of strawberry farmers, “without a thank-you gift in return.”
Compare that with a financial planner in Yokohama who uses the program to stock her pantry with luxuries she wouldn’t otherwise buy. “I don’t usually choose to donate to somewhere because of a connection to the place,” she said. “It’s more because I look at the thank-you gift and think, ‘I really want to eat this thing.’”
The risk is familiar: the reward becomes the reason, and the cause becomes incidental. Behavioral scientists call it “crowding out” when external incentives displace someone’s existing, internal motivation. The standard defense of premiums, which a former version of me repeated, is that they increase response. A Faustian bargain many fundraisers accept: win the battle, lose the lifetime-value war.
But what if the premium doesn’t even win the battle? A public radio station tested that in its member renewal mailings. It had offered premiums elsewhere, including on-air pledge drives, but hadn’t used them in its direct mail campaign.
Researchers randomly divided members into 3 groups with everyone getting the same letter. But one group also got an insulated tumbler offer if the donated $180 or more. Another test group could provide 60 meals through a local food bank at the same giving level.
Both offers lost to the standard appeal, which reminded members why they valued public radio. Response fell from 6.9% without an extra offer to 4.0% with the tumbler and 3.5% with the meals. Adding another reason to give brought in fewer donors.
The eye-catching offers diverted attention from supporting public radio toward evaluating a deal. Even an offer to help someone else can distract from the reason someone supports you.
The decline was concentrated among people who’d given larger amounts the previous year. That’s consistent with crowding out stronger existing motivation, although the study didn’t directly measure their commitment.
Before adding another reason to give, check whether you’re obscuring the one donors already have. And don’t offer the welding lessons unless you know they’re aspiring welders.
Kevin


